Discussione iniziata da El Jevi
Juan M Leria
Why is FJ topic split in four??
Why is FJ topic split in four??
30 May 2014, 15:58
Burkhard D
Because FJ-1 and FJ-4 cannot be from the same mold. Similar to McDD F/A-18A versus Boeing F/A-18E.
Because FJ-1 and FJ-4 cannot be from the same mold. Similar to McDD F/A-18A versus Boeing F/A-18E.
15 June 2014, 15:01
Augie
Yeah there are too many differences in the FJ-1 to 4 to be covered under same mold.
Yeah there are too many differences in the FJ-1 to 4 to be covered under same mold.
15 June 2014, 16:23
Juan M Leria
The same can be said about:
- Bf 109A and Bf 109K
- Spitfire Mk.I and 24 (not to mention Seafire FR.47!)
- F9F Panther and F9F-8 Cougar
- MiG-21F-13 and MiG-21bis
Moreover, the differences between FJ-2 and FJ-3 are as much as between F-4B and F-4G or Mirage IIIC and IIIE.
The same can be said about:
- Bf 109A and Bf 109K
- Spitfire Mk.I and 24 (not to mention Seafire FR.47!)
- F9F Panther and F9F-8 Cougar
- MiG-21F-13 and MiG-21bis
Moreover, the differences between FJ-2 and FJ-3 are as much as between F-4B and F-4G or Mirage IIIC and IIIE.
15 June 2014, 18:45
Augie
Yes, the same can be said. however if the aim is just to simplify families.. then yes they could all be "N.A Fury"
Yes, the same can be said. however if the aim is just to simplify families.. then yes they could all be "N.A Fury"
15 June 2014, 18:50
Burkhard D
The issue is that he FJ-2/-3 belong to the F-86 family while the FJ-1 and the FJ-4 do not and otherwise have nothing in common either. Unlike the Bf109, the MiG-21 and the F9F, these four are no family at all.
The issue is that he FJ-2/-3 belong to the F-86 family while the FJ-1 and the FJ-4 do not and otherwise have nothing in common either. Unlike the Bf109, the MiG-21 and the F9F, these four are no family at all.
15 June 2014, 19:31
Juan M Leria
Do you really think a Bf 109B had something in common with a Bf 109K other than name and some external resemblance? The same is for the MiG-21 or the F9F
Do you really think a Bf 109B had something in common with a Bf 109K other than name and some external resemblance? The same is for the MiG-21 or the F9F
16 June 2014, 11:00
Rex
I know that this is years later, but, "FJ-2/-3 belong to the F-86 family " is very much not the case. Only the three FJ-2 prototypes are F-86s. After those three aircraft, the FJ-2 doesn't even have the same fuselage shape or wings,,,,,,and the FJ-3 has another different fuselage, and another set of wings, compared to the FJ-2.
I know that this is years later, but, "FJ-2/-3 belong to the F-86 family " is very much not the case. Only the three FJ-2 prototypes are F-86s. After those three aircraft, the FJ-2 doesn't even have the same fuselage shape or wings,,,,,,and the FJ-3 has another different fuselage, and another set of wings, compared to the FJ-2.
22 March 2017, 17:26