Scalemates, scale modeling database | stash manager
login | faq | facts | about us | privacy | advertise |
scale modeling database | stash manager
Login 
Offline

 

Thread started by mnorfolk49

Mark Norfolk
So folks, the vast majority of my paints are Humbrol enamel. I have purchased a few Vallejo and one Tamiya acrylic and I'm persuaded of the benefits of an airbrush - something to save for. (For now I will have to brush them on: one thing I have learnt in recent weeks is why my attempts to brush paint Tamiya Acrylics failed so abysmally 30 years ago!). What I am interested in though is any views on the quality difference between Humbrol and Tamiya enamels. I wasn't fussed until I found the latter readily available on ebay and it got me to wondering. Anyone with experience of both have a view?
25. June at 13:26:48 Share
Olivier 30 years ago acrylics were not so frequent. Humbrol enamels used to be the reference in the old world.
Nowadays I enjoy the AK real colour range but they are acrylics.
25. June at 17:16:28
Augie So I may as well wade in here, as I am known as a brush painter only and my take on the brands.

1) Humbrol (enamels)
Currently, humbrols are a mixed bag quality wise when it comes to brush-ability, they are having in my opinion huge quality issues which means some pots will arrive and the paint is so thick, you can invert the can once opened and the paint does not drip! It thins poorly with 3rd party thinners but fairly well with humbrol own brand. Older Humbrols are still my go to paint and with the right brush and patience will go down without brush marks.

Acrylic

Again they have issues with newer batches, not quite as thick but really do not seem to thin well unless thinking with a mix of iso pro acohol and vms thinners. Older batches cover well with out masses of fuss.

2) Tamyia (Acrylics)

I find with these they need thinning with X-20 thinners when brushing else they dry very quickly. A few drops of VMS Slow-mo makes them easy enough to work with. Another factor with these is room temperature anything over about 22 room temp and unless you thin excessively then they are hard work.

3) Vallejo (Acrylics)

Used a few of these and have never really had to do anything with them to brush with. They just work.

4) Hataka (Acrylic)

I've used the "brush" and "airbrush" ones of these and find again they just work with brush, minimal fuss but to my mind expensive.

5) Revell (Both)

Revell enamels, I find are quick thick and need thinning down with own brand thinners to get a nice consistent smooth finish. They don't have the quite the same issues with 3rd party thinners, they react well to humbrol thinners, but poorly to VMS thinners.

Acrylic

I quite like them, react well to VMS thinners and go on nice and smooth without too much fuss.
25. June at 17:50:59
Mark Norfolk Thanks Augie - that's very helpful & informative. I have found what you describe with Humbrol - not as extreme but yes some thicker, some thinner. Loads for me to take on board though - thank you so much.
25. June at 19:07:18
Mark Norfolk Olivier - please excuse my ignorance but what does AK stand for? I have not heard of that brand. Thanks.
25. June at 19:09:42
Derek Huggett @ Augie - Pearls of wisdom from the High Priestess of the Hairy Stick! I have found very similar results over the years. Very useful views/comments for those of us who still don't 'blow' our finishes! :)
25. June at 19:45:46
Augie Welcome mark, glad to help
Derek, its nice to see others who still dont rely on blow ;)
25. June at 20:55:35
Mark Norfolk Thanks Olivier! :)
26. June at 05:18:26
Add comment »

Newsfeed

 

Join us now!
33.000+ plastic modelers use us
315 online...

New releases

1:48 Messerschmitt Bf 109G-6 (Kora Models NDT48024)
1:48 Messerschmitt Bf 109G-6 Jabo (Kora Models NDT48025)
1:48 Messerschmitt Bf 109GA-6/Bf 109G-6 (Kora Models NDT48026)
 
View more »


Hot kits

1:48 B-17G (HK Models 01F001)
1:48 Chattanooga Choo Choo (Eduard 11134)
1:35 USMC AH-1Z (Academy 12127)
 
View more »
 


Upcoming events

30. Modellbauausstellung des PMC Main-Kinzig in Gelnhausen-Meerholz
5. and 6. October | DE Gelnhausen-Meerholz
Augsburger Modellbautage in Augsburg
5. and 6. October | DE Augsburg
 
5. and 6. October | CH Cossonay
IPMS Vancouver Annual Fall Model Show and Swap Meet in Burnaby, BC
11. October | CA Burnaby, BC

View more »
© 2010-2019 scalemates | about us | privacy | advertise | links

We use cookies to give you a great and free experience on our website. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

You can change your Cookie settings at any time. (Essential cookies are for: preferences, security, performance analytics and contextual advertising)

Privacy policy »     Continue